Reviews - Furnace Compare

Mahoning Wood Furnace Reviews

"17 years and still going"

5.0 rating
Very Satisfied

I have had my Mahoning outside Wood stove for 17 years I heat my 3100 sq ft. Home with it in 17 years. I replaced a blower and a pump still going. Have had people tell me I'm on borrowed time with the stove when it dies will definitely replace with another Mahoning stove.

C Skelly

Tioga, PA


5.0 rating
Very Satisfied

I bought my Mahoning used and have been running it for 3 winters. It's an amazing stove. I did the installation myself. Starting from scratch, it's a little bit of a project, but otherwise not hard. If you have all your parts, pieces, tools, equipment, and an avid diy guy….it's a long Saturday. I used pvc and pipe insulation for the water lines, bought an exchanger online, and installed it in my forced air furnace. I installed a second thermostat for the boiler. That way if you go away and your stove goes out, you can rely on your gas heat to keep your house warm. I'm lucky to have an older model (pre-government regs) with the larger door. If you're looking at a used one, the good ones will have a 22" x 22" door. I believe the new models are 18 x 18". I don't want to discourage anyone from purchasing a new Mahoning but the larger door is much more accommodating for large chunks of wood. This stove will devour small wood like a fat man eating M&M's especially when it's below freezing. The larger and less seasoned wood will go much farther. I cut and split boat anchors that I have to wrestle into the stove. I know this is not for everyone, no worries, but be prepared to burn a considerable amount of wood. Depending on the size of wood, mild winter (32 degrees and above) you'll only need to load once. Hard winter, you're looking at twice a day, with an easy 12 to 15 hour window. All in all…great investment. I only pay the distribution fee for natural gas ($16 a month) and my home has never been warmer. Like a long, long hot shower? It's an endless supply! Love my Mahoning!


Shinglehouse, PA

"Great unit"

5.0 rating
Very Satisfied

Great unit. I heat a 2,000 square foot home and domestic hot water in the winter and a 15,000 gallon swimming pool in the summer. I burn wood and coal when the temperature is below 32 degrees and only wood when temperatures are above 32 degrees. I never have any trouble keeping my home warm now and have all of the hot water I can use. I completed the installation is about two weeks in my free time. Everything is prewired and the only connection needed is as simple as wiring a plug. Up to this point I had never worked with PEX pipe so I was a little apprehensive but after a few connections I will have a hard time going back to anything else. The dealer I bought the boiler from recommended a 6" sewer pipe to run my PEX in and it worked great. I measured my run from the boiler pad to the inside boiler room and added 6' of extra PEX for each connection. I used two 1" lines, two 3/4" lines, a 1/2" line, and a 1/4" pull rope. I then wrapped the five lines and rope in a silver bubble wrap then finished with duct tape. I have had people tell me that when it snows they have a bare spot where the lines are run under ground. I do not have that problem so I assume that the insulation is working good. I have about a 100' run to the house and experience about a 8 degree heat loss in that distance. My only regret is that I didn't do this sooner.


Garrett County, MD

"10 years going strong"

5.0 rating
Very Satisfied

I have a 10 year old Mahoning 200 that heats a 2800 square foot house in central Pennsylvania. It uses plenty of wood when very cold, but heats all our hot water year round with little wood in warm months. When coupled with an indirect fired hot water heater you will not run out of hot water. The only thing I have replaced is a the blower fan in the back and it was an easy swap for a do-it-yourself handyman. No complaints to speak of other than the amount of wood they require. They are simply designed, and seem built to last. I would buy from Mahoning again.

C Stine

Skook, PA

"Best investement we ever made!"

5.0 rating
Very Satisfied

We are on the third winter of using our outdoor woodstove. I love the fact that all the mess is outside, no more inside burning. We only have to fill it twice a day when its below 30, once when its nicer out. We can have the house really warm and it just uses a little more wood. Much less expensive than oil or gas. The only thing I don't like is you have to have someone tend to it if you go away in the winter. But that's easily fixed if you get the wood to oil converter, which will switch over and burn oil if you are away. We have only had to have one minor repair on it which was a fuse in the box because lightning struck it during a bad thunderstorm one time. It is about due for a new rope around the door to keep it sealed, smoke is starting to seep out through the door every so often. I would definitely recommend this brand to a friend. If I was starting over I would definitely buy this brand again.

Middleburg, PA

HVAC Brands

Learn more about your home's heating and cooling system with our guides, how-to's, FAQ's, tips and more.

Ready to get a quote from an HVAC contractor?

Let us know what type of service you need and we can connect you with a certified local HVAC contractor.

Please enter a valid name

Please enter a valid phone number

Please enter a valid zip code

There are no dealers in this zip code.

Please enter a valid email address

Please select repair or replace

Please select heating, cooling or both