Find Local Contractors

1. I need a new:

2. My zip code is:

Carrier 58MCA Furnace

2.3 of 5 stars 7 reviews | #15 of 21 Furnaces
Updated: Jan 7, 2018 | Read more about Carrier Furnaces | 58MCA Warranty

Overview of 58MCA

The Carrier 58MCA is a residential natural gas furnace. This high-efficiency series has an AFUE efficiency rating that ranges from 91 - 92.1%. The first year that this furnace appears in our records is 2002.

Furnace Filters for the Carrier 58MCA

Air Flow Configuration Cabinet Width Filters
All 17-1/2" 1 16x25x1 filter
(bottom air return)
All 21" 1 20x25x1 filter
(bottom air return)
All 24-1/2" 1 24x25x1 filter
(bottom air return)
All All 1 16x25x1 filter
(side air return)

Consumer Reviews of the 58MCA

2.3 2.3 of 5 stars 7 reviews
  • Very Satisfied
  • Somewhat Satisfied
  • Neutral
  • Somewhat Unsatisfied
  • Very Unsatisfied
best product icon  What are the 10 Best Furnaces?
5 of 5 stars Palmyra, PA
Date created: 2018-01-07

Never a problem

I bought the house over four years ago, I assume the furnace and a/c unit are original equipment from 1999-2000. Iíve never had a problem with either unit, I was just doing some research in the event the ac unit would go. I assume it should be nearing the end of it useful life. When I had a restaurant I had a Lennox furnace, that was one of the worst furnaces I ever had, a plumber friend of mine replaced the boards on it three times, and it still would not fire up unless I manually lit it with a match. This Carrier has been perfect.

1 of 5 stars Beaumont, AB
Date created: 2018-01-03

Worst furnace I have ever had

Worst furnace I have ever had,tis one is 8 years old,spent $800,00 to fix it 2 years ago,now it needs a new hear exchanger, we have had no hear through this cold spell of -30, we have been waiting for parts for 8 days now. What a pile of shit

5 of 5 stars Minnesota
Date created: 2017-08-01

Never a problem

15 years and counting without an issue.

1 of 5 stars Rhode Island
Date created: 2016-10-05

Expensive mistake

We bought a top of the line, energy efficient gas furnace. The heat exchanger failed after only 9 years. Joke of a warranty covered the $600 replacement part but not the 14 hours of labor - that cost us $3,500! Never buy Carrier.

1 of 5 stars Edmonton, Alberta
Date created: 2015-10-24

Worst furnace ever

No warranty, constantly breaks down! Utter garbage! I will never buy Carrier again!

2 of 5 stars Kansas City, KS
Date created: 2014-01-22

Not happy

Our unit was put in as a new build. The unit is noisy and seems to run a lot. We got it for the efficiency and I think most of our beef is with the installation. Ours has only one pipe to the outside meaning the air intake is from the house. We also have foam insulation which means our house is pretty air tight. Today is the third service call for no heat. We do have it maintained twice a year by a licensed technician, so not from misuse. Three and a half years in service and I wish we could could just chuck it for another. We also got taken by the warranty 90 day registration crap since we weren't even in the house by then. Seems dishonest to give double the warranty just because you told them about installing their product.

1 of 5 stars Lexington KY
Date created: 2011-11-14

Noise problem is "normal"?

I have just had a furnace/ac installed - the 90% efficiency gas base furnace by Carrier. The furnace seems to work okay heating but there is a high pitched hum, like someone blowing over the top of an open Coke bottle, coming from the furnace. The install company says this is "normal." After several hours of service calls (during which they discovered and fixed an off-center blower wheel), they are blaming my ductwork when the sound is clearly coming from the unit. If this is what Carrier considers normal, then I would not recommend this brand. I have had a high efficiency Lennox and a high efficiency American Standard installed in the past in very similar houses. These units worked fine and were quiet. Not sure if this is Carrier or the installer, but I am not pleased with the unit.

Other 58MCA Reviews

Find Local Contractors
1. I need a new:
2. My zip code is:

Carrier 58MCA Model Numbers

The 58MCA is available in different models which vary in efficiency and capacity.

Model Number AFUE BTUs per Hour
58MCA040-08 92.1 40,000
58MCA040-08* 91 40,000
58MCA040-12 92.1 40,000
58MCA040-12* 91 40,000
58MCA060-08 92.1 60,000
58MCA060-08* 91 60,000
58MCA060-12 92.1 60,000
58MCA060-12* 91 60,000
58MCA060-16 92.1 60,000
58MCA060-16* 91 60,000
58MCA080-12 92.1 80,000
58MCA080-12* 91 80,000
58MCA080-16 92.1 80,000
58MCA080-16* 91 80,000
58MCA080-20 92.1 80,000
58MCA080-20* 91 80,000
58MCA100-16 92.1 100,000
58MCA100-16* 91 100,000
58MCA100-20 92.1 100,000
58MCA100-20* 91 100,000
58MCA120-20 92.1 120,000
58MCA120-20* 91 120,000
58MCA140-20 92.1 138,000
58MCA140-20* 91 138,000

58MCA Warranty

Copyright 2002 - 2019