We speak HVAC so you don't have to
Find Local Contractors

1. I need a new:

2. My zip code is:

Find Local Contractors

1. I need a new:

2. My zip code is:

Furnace Ratings by Brand

Updated: Nov. 3, 2017

Furnace Ratings as Determined by Consumer Ratings

  1. Clare
  2. Olsen
  3. Frigidaire
  4. York
  5. Luxaire
  6. Comfortmaker
  7. Coleman
  8. Maytag
  9. Rheem
  10. Ruud
  11. Amana
  12. Armstrong Air
  13. Trane
  14. Goodman
  15. Heil
  16. Bryant
  17. Aire Flo
  18. Gibson
  19. Payne
  20. Lennox
  21. Janitrol
  22. Tempstar
  23. American Standard
  24. Arcoaire
  25. Ducane
  26. Carrier
  27. Weatherking
  28. Keeprite
  29. Evcon
  30. Burnham
  31. Buderus

When a homeowner searches for furnace ratings they typically want to know how other consumers rate the furnaces that they own. FurnaceCompare.com has collected thousands of consumer reviews since we began collecting them in 2006. In addition to writing a long-form review, reviewers also rate each furnace model from 1 ("Very Unsatisfied") to 5 ("Very Satisfied"). The previous list ranks furnaces from best to worst.

We have collected reviews on more than 65 different brands of furnaces -- however, we have not included all those brands in the list above. If we have only collected a handful of reviews, we run the risk that a single homeowner might affect the average rating too far in one direction or another. For that reason, we have only included the average rating for brands that at least 25 consumers have reviewed. However, all of our furnace reviews are available here.

Brands with the Highest Fleet Efficiency

There is a second type of furnace rating -- a unit's efficiency rating. A warm-air furnace's efficiency rating is typically measured by its AFUE (Annual Fuel Utilization Efficiency). The "fleet efficiency" of a particular brand is the average efficiency of all of the models sold under that brand name.

Natural Gas Furnaces (with more than 100 models)

  1. Aire-Flo
  2. Payne Heating & Cooling
  3. Trane

Natural Gas Furnaces (with 100 or fewer models)

  1. Kenmore
  2. Clare
  3. DMO Industries

Oil Furnaces (all brands)

  1. Columbia Boilers
  2. Boyertown Furnace Company
  3. Clare
  4. DMO Industries

Notes on Furnace Ratings

The "fleet efficiency" or "furnace rating" of a particular furnace brand indicates nothing about furnace quality or furnace durability. In addition, although the fleet efficiency of one brand might exceed that of another, this does not necessarily indicate that any particular model of furnace marketed under the first brand out-performs any particular model of furnace marketed under the second. To determine whether one model outperforms another, simple compare the AFUE of the two models.

Copyright 2002 - 2017 furnacecompare.com